Nestled in the heart of Muskoka, Huntsville, Ontario, is not just a haven for nature lovers but also a burgeoning hotspot for foodies. With a culinary scene that’s as vibrant as its picturesque landscapes, Huntsville is home to restaurants that are redefining dining in small-town Canada.
Among them, these are some of our favourite standouts, creating waves for their unique offerings and ambience, they epitomize the innovative spirit of Huntsville’s food scene, drawing locals and tourists alike.
1. BeaverTails
69 Main St. E.
BeaverTails, an iconic Canadian franchise since 1978, has made its mark in Huntsville with its unmistakable take on the classic Canadian pastry. Known for its hand-stretched, fried dough shaped like a beaver’s tail, this spot is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. What makes it cool? Beyond its deliciously unique treat, its laid-back vibe allows you to enjoy a quintessentially Canadian snack while taking in the town’s natural beauty. The most popular dish is the “Classic Cinnamon & Sugar BeaverTail,” it’s a simple yet irresistible delight. Great snack spot while browsing Huntsville’s downtown strip.
2. That Little Place By the Lights ( @that.little.place.muskoka)
76 Main St E.
That Little Place By the Lights stands as a testament to Huntsville’s charm. This family-owned restaurant has quickly become the town’s favourite Italian restaurant, specializing in home-cooked Italian pasta (gluten-free options are available), lasagna, gnocchi, homemade gelato, and pizza, with recipes handed down from their Nonna. Its popularity isn’t just due to its inviting setting but also because of its commitment to delivering unforgettable meals. The most raved-about dish?
Nonna Annie’s Famous Lasagna, features layers of homemade lasagna noodles, bechamel and Bolognese sauce.
The Mushroom Ravioli, a creamy, earthy delight that perfectly encapsulates the essence of local cuisine.
That Little Place By the Lights stands as a testament to Huntsville’s charm. This family-owned restaurant has quickly become the town’s favourite Italian restaurant, specializing in home-cooked Italian pasta (gluten-free options are available), lasagna, gnocchi, homemade gelato, and pizza, with recipes handed down from their Nonna. Its popularity isn’t just due to its inviting setting but also because of its commitment to delivering unforgettable meals. The most raved-about dish?
You can’t go wrong with any of their 12” pizzas.
They also have a bar that offers a secret menu, with drinks like Provence Paloma (Tequila, Rose, Elderflower Liquer and Grapefruit soda).
After your meal, be sure to check out their little mercato in the back of the restaurant, where they offer frozen and fresh meals, in small or family sized portions, perfect for when you have those large family gatherings and could use a little help with entertaining meals. You can order online and pick-up (delivery not available at this time).
Their commitment to quality and the community speaks volumes, making it a beloved spot among residents and visitors.
Check out our interview with the owner, Matty Buttus.
3. On the Docks Pub ( @OnTheDocksPub )
90 Main St. E.
This is the spot on the main strip that crowds love to flock to for its awesome pub food and a wide range of beer. There are 3 outdoor patios where guests can enjoy gorgeous waterfront views. Pub favourites include: Docks Chicken Sandwich, Beef Dip and Jerk Chicken Wrap, a selection of fish, shrimp, chicken or steak tacos, wings, wraps, burgers, Thai mussels, pretzel bites + cheese dip, flatbread pizzas and more.
4. Marigold Unique Flavours (@marigoldflavours)
171 Main St. E.
Marigold Unique Flavours prides itself on delivering the very best Indian cuisine, with their chef’s unique twist, coupled with excellent customer service and incredible ambiance, they also serve Indo-Chinese and Thai dishes.
Fragrant, pungent, and warm spices from the four corners of the country are delicately blended in meticulous proportions to create their dishes.
5. 3 Guys and A Stove ( @3GuysAndAStove )
143 Hwy 60
Casual fine dining, offering Canadian fare, served in a quaint, old log home mansion, turned restaurant, with 2 dining levels and a patio. Reservations are required, as this place is widely regarded as one of Huntsville’s top places to eat.
Walk in the door and one of the chefs cooking something that smells wonderful and tastes even better greets you with a ‘Hi, welcome to ‘3 Guys’! The hostess smiles and seats you on one of the two levels, each with a fireplace for the cooler months. In the summer guests may dine outside on one of the two decks, weather permitting.
Now it is time for the main event…Canadian food at its most elevated! Bite into the best Caesar salad around, then move onto the entrees like ribs, steak, stew, over a dozen outstanding vegetarian dishes and more. Their desserts are delicious, like their famous White Chocolate Cheesecake…wow! Or finish your meal by sipping on a perfectly made cappuccino.
The kids’ menu is a constant hit with kids and Mom & Dad. The lively music is upbeat and yet allows conversations for couples, friends, families and special events.
Great food, packed with flavour, great ambiance and excellent service are waiting for you at 3 Guys And A Stove. Their full menu is also available for catering at a venue of your choice or you can rent one of their dining rooms for your own private gathering.
Huntsville’s culinary scene is a blend of tradition and innovation, whether you’re craving a sweet, iconic Canadian treat or a sophisticated, locally inspired meal, these restaurants offer experiences that are as memorable as they are delicious. So, the next time you find yourself in Huntsville, don’t miss the chance to explore these trendy eateries, they’re setting the standard for dining in cottage country. Don’t forget to follow these spots on social media to stay updated on their latest offerings and events. Bon appétit!
